“Why I won’t march….” an opinion

Karen Shexnayder

Submitted by Karen Schexnayder

For the past 45 years I’ve watched as people threw hurtful glances and spoke words that cut like a knife at my brother, who is deaf, mentally retarded and has autism. I often wondered why someone would do this to a person, who is already hurting. It wasn’t just uneducated people who did this. No, it has been people from every walk of life and economic status – folks who purported to be ‘good people’ – those who attend church, leaders in the community, moms and dads raising children.

 

 

As a sibling of someone with special needs, I’ve learned that to change a person’s perspective, it takes education and communication. It requires standing up and speaking for those who cannot. The needle moves in the right direction one person at a time. To me, a march in Washington or Amelia Island is not going to change the opinion of someone who sees those with disabilities as unworthy. You have to get to the bottom as to why they feel that way, then slowly educate that person about individuals with disabilities, what the medical diagnosis really means and how if given the right opportunities, the disabled can flourish.

I’m not a very political person and in fact, I tend to back away from political conversations. I won’t be waving a party flag or sporting a candidate’s swag. Like many, I feel as though the leaders of our country have become removed from what the ‘average’ person feels and needs. I believe those who want to truly effect change get involved in the everyday trenches of life.

If we want our daughters, nieces, granddaughters and all little girls to break the proverbial glass ceiling, we need to be the role models they need to see in life. I was fortunate to have been raised by parents who encouraged me to dream big and provided me the opportunities to achieve my goals. Sadly, there are girls whose dreams are being extinguished, many, right here in our backyard.

Across Nassau County there are organizations such as Take Stock in Children, the Boys and Girls Club and Communities in Schools, among others, who need us to inspire children, to be their hope when they have none and to encourage them to shoot for the stratosphere. We need to champion girls who want to be engineers, mathematicians and scientists. Our children need us to help navigate the seas of adolescence and be their anchor when they feel they’re floating away from their goals.

There are women in shelters who need our counsel, support and strength to move beyond abusive relationships. There are folks with disabilities who work at our local restaurants and retailers. They need our kindness and we need to give them confidence in themselves.

If we want our voices to be heard, we need to speak by doing the things we feel need changed. Imagine if everyone who plans to march on Saturday would walk into a school, nonprofit or woman’s shelter and ask, “How may I help?” Those who selflessly give of their time and talents to make their community better, make the biggest impact.

I’ve been my brother’s voice countless times. I’ve reminded people that while he may be deaf, he sees how he and those like him are treated and it hurts. Instead of marching, I chose to be a voice.

 

16 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Debbie Skinner
Debbie Skinner (@guest_48377)
7 years ago

I don’t believe this is an either-or proposition. I know several people who are planning to participate in the march – and each and every one of them also gives generously of their time and talent to improve our community on a daily basis. To imply that there is a choice – march or help the community – is disingenuous. Why not do both?

Wilma Allen
Wilma Allen(@wilmaa65gmail-com)
7 years ago

Very nicely said. Service to others is always admirable as is speaking up for others. However, it is possible to march and help at the same time. I know many of the people who will march or watch from the sidelines tomorrow have been helping others for decades. And I’m sure they will continue long beyond when the march is over.

steven Crounse
steven Crounse (@guest_48379)
7 years ago

Karen, I think you’re missing the whole point of this march. their will be over 1,000 participants. I know many of these folks, I’ve worked shoulder to shoulder with many. I’ll bet if you joined us and had conversations, you’d find the Majority, work with Youth Groups, Church Groups, Meals on Wheels, Gracie’s Kitchen, Senior living, Environmental Groups, Folks with Disabilities, and the Deaf Community. When we have a gathering such as this march, these are the Folks that always participate. Of course we are “Preaching to the Choir” but every once in awhile there is someone like you who would like to affect a change. It’s all about Womens Rights and Human Rights and Respect for all, It’s a Social Statement and the Concerns we have with Society in General, and the Political Firestorm that’s taking place in America at this Moment. Join us, Karen, I bet you can find an organization amongst us, that you can become a part of, and contribute to.

Bevin Cassel
Bevin Cassel (@guest_48385)
7 years ago
Reply to  steven Crounse

It is NOT about all human rights. If it were, pro life groups would be welcome at the march

steven Crounse
steven Crounse (@guest_48390)
7 years ago
Reply to  Bevin Cassel

Pro-life could have joined the march, No one, No one would have stopped them, They Chose not to Participate. It was open to All. BTW Just returned Home from the March, There was not a Thousand that showed up as registered. But Est. of 2,500 people Marched. Is this the Largest March ever in our City,?? These were of all Strips. Many more went to Washington DC for the “HUMAN RIGHTS” March. Fernandina Beach, I’ve never been more proud of my Neighbors. Thank You All, But remember. This Is Just The Start.!!! We have a Rocky Road Ahead. Ps. Karen, Did you make it.?

Nannette Mroz
Nannette Mroz (@guest_48424)
7 years ago
Reply to  steven Crounse

They showed up and we’re asked to leave in d.c.

Genece Minshew
Genece Minshew (@guest_48381)
7 years ago

Thank you Steve Crouse. Could not have said it better myself. As someone who has worked to improve women’s lives both politically and individually for over 40 years, with batter women and rape victims before it was socially acceptable, with ensuring women had access to safe and affordable reproductive healthcare, I find it hard to be told that my voice does not need to be raised today

Genece Minshew
Genece Minshew (@guest_48382)
7 years ago
Mac Morriss
Mac Morriss(@macmorrisshotmail-com)
7 years ago

Karen, I admire your courage in speaking out for your beliefs. There will be those who miss the point you are making. God bless you and your family.

Mary Maguire
Mary Maguire (@guest_48386)
7 years ago

The first sentence of this commentary surprised me. Off topic, but I thought ARC of the United States changed its name decades ago because part of the name was considered offensive.

Ben Lloyd
Ben Lloyd (@guest_48387)
7 years ago
Reply to  Mary Maguire

It used to be called Association for Retarded Citizens, but it was shortened to just The Arc. They are affiliated with The Arc of the United States. There is no acronym anymore.

Nann Mroz
Nann Mroz (@guest_48388)
7 years ago

Why I can’t march. Because women who are pro-life or apparently work excluded from the march. So much for the all-inclusive women’s march. This is a shame because for all the stance about how unified women should be clearly they’re not. Women should have control over their own bodies so should The Unborn girls who will never have a chance to grow into women.

Abigail Legg
Abigail Legg (@guest_48389)
7 years ago

I believe all welcome, it’s just asked we don’t carry our specific issue sign – pro choice / pro life / – Up Trump / Down Trump and on and on – Let’s think bigger today than one issue that we don’t agree on and support all women.

N Mroz
N Mroz (@guest_48391)
7 years ago
Reply to  Abigail Legg

Once again, much like what is happening in this country right now, fact and believe are 2 different things: http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/excluded-pro-life-group-womens-march-organizers-espouse-a-specific-type-of-diversity/article/2612565

Thomas C. Washburn
Thomas C. Washburn (@guest_48398)
7 years ago

Women’s Rights are Human Rights! Since this nation’s founding, too many of our political leaders have acted so as to produce a culture that shows wide gaps between parties, among ethnic and gender communities, and among financial classes. One serious corollary of these gaps is the failure to honor our basic human rights.
I think that the global and the Fernandina Beach marches were appropriate for our coming together, but we all must continue to come together to bring our culture to a better place for all of us.

Christine Platel
Christine Platel(@cplatelbellsouth-net)
7 years ago

As one of the three organizers of the Amelia Island Solidarity March, along with Sheila Cocchi, and Amy Tompkins, I would like to say how very proud we are of all the Marchers who showed up; not only from our community, but from other parts of NE Florida, and SE Georgia as well. They believe in standing up for human rights; and will continue doing so. As many commentators have already stated, these are people who care deeply; and many already volunteer their time and energy here, or in their own communities. As an Official Sister March of The Women’s March on Washington, we stand with their ideals: “The work of this march is not only to stand together in sisterhood and solidarity for the protection of our rights, our safety, our families, and our environment — but it is also to build relationships and mend the divides between our communities. It’s hard work, and it will be ongoing. It’s an ambitious goal – one that reaches far beyond January 21st – but we believe that there is no other way forward. Only together can we march towards freedom.” This includes fighting for the rights of your brother, Karen, at local, State, and Federal levels. By the way, our official number, as supported by video and other data, is 1400 Marchers.