What’s With Atlantic Seafood? Good Question, No Answers

By Mike Lednovich

When developer Ernie Saltmarsh assumed the lease on the failing Atlantic Seafood building in August 2022, he was required to submit plans for a new structure to the city. Now more than a year later, no plans have been submitted and the city commission has not addressed the status of replacing the building.

The current Atlantic Seafood structure, which is in such dilapidated condition that it cannot get insurance, was the focus of Wednesday’s Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Board (CRAAB) meeting. CRAAB member Eric Bartelt asked City Attorney Tammi Bach about Atlantic Seafood and “what is it going to take to get this moving forward?”

“It takes money and approval of a plan and Mr. Saltmarsh has made it clear both publicly and in individual meetings with city commissioners that between him and his architect, he needs to fit at least 150 seats in that restaurant in order to make it work,” Bach said.

“By doing that he is trying to find a design that is going to fit all the ADA-accessible bathrooms. I’m almost certain he will want a second story of some type even if it’s just a deck so he’ll have to have an elevator with new construction. Making room for all those and 150 seats and a kitchen and storage is what I think he is struggling to do.”

CRAAB Chair Lisa Finkelstein said community frustration had built “because there hasn’t been communication (about the project) for so long.”

Bach said city staff had moved on from the Atlantic Seafood issue since no discussion about the building had taken place since a December 2022 City Commission meeting.

At that meeting, Saltmarsh submitted plans for a seafood store and a restaurant that was 4,815 square feet, including the building, porches, decks and other areas such as ramps and steps. The current Atlantic Seafood building is 1,200 square feet. That plan was rejected and Saltmarsh was instructed to submit a new plan.

“As staff, including me, the last thing we remember was Mr. Saltmarsh here at a public meeting and the commission was not going to approve or even a nod to that plan they thought was too big. I can tell you city staff, we move on to other things and that (Atlantic Seafood) moves to the bottom of the pile,” Bach said.

Bach said she sent Saltmarsh an email several months ago asking for an update, “but that was when Mr. Saltmarsh was dealing with a family issue.”

There is a deadline for replacing Atlantic Seafood since the building will have to be demolished to finish the flood protection wall to the city marina boat ramp. That construction is awaiting design and funding.

“How do we get this building gone, moved, improved? It’s going to be through demolition and a new structure,” Bach said. “In about 18 months the city is going to be, we think, ready and need to demolish the structure so that the seawall can be constructed in that location. Under the lease, they have to leave the building. So, if there is no plan and no place else to go, they have the right to build up to 1,200 square feet.”

Bach said Saltmarsh is talking with each city commissioner about a “new plan,” but said the revised plan is still about 4,000 square feet.

As far as a timeline for a new building, Bach told CRAAB members “you may ask how long? I can’t answer that, you’ll have to ask your city commissioners.”

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Noble Member
6 months ago

He’s talking with each commissioner? Those conversations better be public record.

Trusted Member
6 months ago

Maybe he made a bad business deal. There’s a big difference between 1200 and almost 5000 feet. It’s his problem that he needs 15 seats to be profitable. Where are all of those who normally pile on about losing parking and the view?

Alan Hopkins
Noble Member
Alan Hopkins(@dawaves)
6 months ago

So nothing is getting done. Not surprised but I feel for the CRABB members. Lots of time and effort that results in little or nothing getting done. Not their fault. Still waiting on all the additional parking spaces that the committee found last year to come to fruition. Not holding my breath.